Appeals Court Reinstates Charges Against Lawrence County Man, Jury Trial Set for March 2027
The Indiana Court of Appeals has reversed a Lawrence County judge’s decision to throw out criminal charges against Jeremy A. Small. The court ruled that Small waited too long to object to a trial date that fell outside Indiana’s one-year speedy trial deadline.
The three-judge panel handed down its ruling on November 5, 2026. Judge Mathias wrote the decision, and Judges Pyle and Weissmann concurred.
The same day, Lawrence Superior Court 2 reinstated all four charges and set a new jury trial for March 2, 2027.
Small is charged with:
- Neglect of a dependent, a Level 6 felony
- Resisting law enforcement, a Class A misdemeanor
- Reckless driving, a Class C misdemeanor
- Refusal to identify self, a Class C misdemeanor
The charges are allegations only. Small has not been convicted and is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
THE ISSUE
Indiana Criminal Rule 4(C) generally requires the State to bring a defendant to trial within one year of being charged or arrested, whichever is later. Delays caused by the defendant, a crowded court calendar or an emergency do not count against that year. If the State goes past the deadline and the defendant asks for dismissal, the charges must be dismissed.
But Indiana courts have long held that a defendant must speak up. If a judge sets a trial date past the one-year deadline, the defendant has to object while there is still time to hold the trial on time. If the defendant stays silent, the law treats it as agreeing to the later date.
THE ORIGINAL CASE
Small was arrested on October 6, 2022. The next day, the State charged him with misdemeanor resisting law enforcement and refusal to identify. That started the one-year clock.
At his initial hearing on October 18, 2022, the court set an omnibus date of December 2, 2022, and a pretrial conference for January 18, 2023.
On November 7, 2022, Small asked for a jury trial. The court set the trial for July 12, 2023.
On June 27, 2023, the court canceled that trial on its own motion and moved it to October 19, 2023.
On October 5, 2023, the State dismissed the misdemeanor charges without prejudice, which meant they could be refiled.
THE REFILED CASE
On October 19, 2023, the State refiled the charges and added the felony neglect of a dependent and misdemeanor reckless driving counts. The new case was filed in Lawrence Superior Court 1 under cause number 47D01-2310-F6-1462.
On October 23, 2023, Judge John M. Plummer III denied the State’s request for an arrest warrant and issued a summons ordering Small to appear in court instead. The sheriff’s office served the summons on October 24.
At his initial hearing on November 28, 2023, the court entered a not guilty plea on Small’s behalf. The judge set an omnibus date of January 29, 2024, a pretrial conference for February 7, 2024, and a jury trial for May 15, 2024. Small did not object to that trial date.
Over the next two years, the trial was pushed back again and again:
- March 2024: The defense asked for a continuance. The trial was moved to October 30, 2024. The court later moved it up to October 9, 2024, on its own motion.
- September 2024: Small’s private attorney asked to withdraw. After a hearing on September 23, 2024, the judge granted the request, appointed the Lawrence County Public Defender Agency, and moved the trial to January 8, 2025. The court’s entry says Criminal Rule 4 time was “charged to the Defendant.”
- October 2024: The defense asked for another continuance. The trial was moved to June 11, 2025.
- May 2025: The court moved the trial to July 16, 2025, on its own motion.
- June 2025: The defense asked for another continuance. Senior Judge Stephen R. Galvin granted it and moved the trial to January 14, 2026.
- January 2026: The State and defense filed a joint motion to continue. At the defense’s request, the trial was moved to February 25, 2026.
Small went through several attorneys during the case. In February 2026, he asked the court to remove his public defender and appoint new counsel. The court agreed, and attorney Jonathan J. McNeil was appointed as special public defender.
On February 10, 2026, the case was moved from Superior Court 1 to Superior Court 2, now cause number 47D02-2310-F6-1462. The trial was reset for March 27, 2026. That same day, Small filed a request to temporarily unseal records of a prior arrest and dismissed charges.
THE DISMISSAL
In mid-February 2026, Small filed a motion asking the court to discharge him and dismiss all charges under Criminal Rule 4. The State objected.
Before the hearing, four of Small’s former attorneys, Denise Turner, Carl Lamb, Adam Larimer and Timothy Sledd, asked the court to quash subpoenas issued to them. The State objected, and Judge Robert R. Cline denied all four requests on February 24, 2026. Larimer and Sledd then asked the judge to reconsider.
On February 25, 2026, Senior Judge William G. Sleva held a hearing on the motion. He ruled that the State had not brought Small to trial within the one-year limit and dismissed all four charges. The March 27 trial was canceled.
On March 3, 2026, the court issued an order of pending expungement. The State asked the court to reconsider, and on March 4 the judge ordered that the expungement stay on hold while the case was on appeal.
The State filed its notice of appeal on March 4. On March 16, the court appointed the Indiana State Public Defender’s office to represent Small on appeal.
WHAT THE APPEALS COURT FOUND
The appeals court went through the timeline day by day.
The 31 days from October 7 to November 7, 2022, counted against the State, which left 334 days.
The State argued that Small’s jury trial request caused a delay and should not count against it. Under Indiana law, the omnibus date in a misdemeanor case is the trial date. The appeals court disagreed. It pointed out that the court had also set a pretrial conference for January 2023, so it was unclear whether a December trial was ever actually scheduled. The court said it was the State’s job to get that cleared up, and it did not.
From November 7, 2022, to June 27, 2023, another 232 days ran off the clock, which left the State 102 days. The clock stopped when the judge moved the trial on the court’s own motion. The State argued Small caused that delay, but the appeals court said the court record shows it was the judge’s decision.
The court said dismissing and refiling charges does not reset the clock. It only pauses it. When the State refiled on October 19, 2023, it had 102 days left, so the deadline was January 28, 2024.
That is where the case turned. In November 2023, the trial court set a May 2024 trial date, well past the deadline. Small had until January 28, 2024, to object, and he did not. Under Indiana law, that meant he accepted the later date. By the time he asked for dismissal in February 2026, it was too late.
The appeals court ruled the dismissal was a mistake, reversed it and sent the case back to Lawrence County.
The ruling is a memorandum decision, so it is not binding precedent for other courts.
WHAT’S NEXT
On November 5, 2026, Judge Cline reinstated McNeil as Small’s attorney, ordered Small to appear in court, and set these dates:
- Pretrial conference and status hearing: December 10, 2026, at 1 p.m.
- Final pretrial conference, motions deadline and change of plea deadline: January 21, 2027, at 1 p.m.
- Jury trial: March 2, 2027, at 8 a.m., as the court’s No. 1 setting
THE ATTORNEYS
Prosecuting Attorney Samuel C. Arp is prosecuting the case. On appeal, the State was represented by Indiana Attorney General Theodore E. Rokita and Deputy Attorney General Jennifer B. Anwarzai. Riley L. Parr of Lebanon represented Small on appeal.
Court of Appeals Case No. 26A-CR-564
Written by
Read next
Police Log 11/12/2026
Bedford Police Department & Lawrence County Sheriff's Department Public Safety Log: November 11 – 12, 2026 All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Arrests & Citations * Skyler Ray Alan Olen (19): Arrested by Bedford Police at 1823 I St on Nov. 11 at 2:41 PM on an active warrant for Petition to Revoke Probation (PTR). Incident Highlights * Personal Injury Collision (Golden Corral): Bedford Police, Lawrence County Sheriff's deputies, and emergency medicaSpringville Man Completes Problem Solving Court, Felony Drug Convictions Entered as Misdemeanors
BEDFORD – A 28-year-old Springville man was sentenced Monday in three drug cases after he successfully completed Lawrence Superior Court II’s Problem Solving Court program. Ethan Ray New appeared Nov. 2 before Judge Robert R. Cline. New spent nearly two years in the program. Because he finished it, the court entered his two felony drug convictions as Class A misdemeanors. New pleaded guilty in all three cases in January 2025. The court took his pleas under advisement while he went through Prob
Lawrence County Man Sentenced to 20 Years on Methamphetamine Dealing Charge
BEDFORD – A Lawrence County man was sentenced Wednesday to 20 years with the Indiana Department of Correction after pleading guilty to dealing methamphetamine. John A. Tegarden appeared Nov. 4 in Lawrence Superior Court II before Judge Robert R. Cline. Tegarden pleaded guilty on Oct. 19 to one count of Dealing in Methamphetamine (10 grams or more), a Level 2 felony. In exchange for his plea, the State dismissed the remaining charges: * A second count of Dealing in Methamphetamine (10 grams o
Mitchell Mother and Son Sentenced to IDOC for Dealing Methamphetamine After Seizure of Over 70 Grams
A joint mother-son narcotics investigation conducted by the Lawrence County Sheriff’s Office has concluded with prison sentences in Lawrence Superior Court 1 for both defendants. Alicia A. Claffey, 49, and her adult son, Cody A. Powell, 21, both of Mitchell, were sentenced to the Indiana Department of Correction (IDOC) after entering negotiated plea agreements with the State of Indiana for dealing methamphetamine. According to the Lawrence County Prosecutor’s Office, the convictions stem from
Police Log 11/17/2026
Bedford Police Department & Lawrence County Sheriff's Department Public Safety Log: November 16 – 17, 2026 All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Incident Highlights * Personal Injury Collisions: * 630 Lincoln Ave (Bedford): Bedford Police and emergency medical responders handled a motor vehicle collision with injuries on Nov. 16 at 3:09 PM. * 12th St (Bedford): BPD, Lawrence County Sheriff's deputies, and EMS responded to an active personal injury
Police Log 11/16/2026
Bedford Police Department & Lawrence County Sheriff's Department Public Safety Log: November 15 – 16, 2026 All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Arrests & Citations * Juvenile (Female, 14), Bedford: Cited/Apprehended by Bedford Police at 1800 block of I St on Nov. 15 at 3:10 PM for Minor Consuming an Alcoholic Beverage. * Juvenile (Male, 17), Bedford: Cited/Apprehended by Bedford Police at 1800 block of I St on Nov. 15 at 3:10 PM for Minor Consuming an
Police Log 11/14/2026
Bedford Police Department & Lawrence County Sheriff's Department Public Safety Log: November 12 – 14, 2026 All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Incident Highlights * Personal Injury Collisions: * Hobson Ford (10050 SR 37, Mitchell): Emergency medical responders and Lawrence County Sheriff's deputies responded to a motor vehicle accident with personal injuries on Nov. 12 at 8:03 AM. * Little Salt Creek Run (Heltonville / Bedford): First responders,