Lawrence County Independent News and Public Records

Court News

Lawrence County Man Sentenced to 20 Years on Methamphetamine Dealing Charge

Lawrence County Man Sentenced to 20 Years on Methamphetamine Dealing Charge

BEDFORD – A Lawrence County man was sentenced Wednesday to 20 years with the Indiana Department of Correction after pleading guilty to dealing methamphetamine.

John A. Tegarden appeared Nov. 4 in Lawrence Superior Court II before Judge Robert R. Cline.

Tegarden pleaded guilty on Oct. 19 to one count of Dealing in Methamphetamine (10 grams or more), a Level 2 felony. In exchange for his plea, the State dismissed the remaining charges:

  • A second count of Dealing in Methamphetamine (10 grams or more), a Level 2 felony
  • Conspiracy to Commit Dealing in Methamphetamine, a Level 2 felony
  • Possession of Methamphetamine (more than 28 grams), a Level 3 felony
  • Possession of a Narcotic Drug (between 10 and 28 grams), a Level 4 felony

Judge Cline sentenced Tegarden to 20 years. Four of those years are suspended to supervised probation, which leaves 16 years to serve. He received credit for 193 days already spent in jail.

Tegarden asked the court to recommend him for the Department of Correction’s Recovery While Incarcerated program, which is an addiction treatment program. The State did not object, and the judge made the recommendation.

After his release, Tegarden will serve four years of supervised probation. His conditions include:

  • No alcohol or illegal drugs, with drug screens
  • Taking part in the Adapt program
  • 80 hours of community service
  • Showing proof of a high school diploma or HSE, or working toward one
  • Completing a local jobs and skills course if he is unemployed

The court imposed court costs and then waived them. Tegarden was ordered to pay a $50 bond fee.

The case was filed Dec. 1, 2025. Tegarden posted a $50,000 cash bond in May 2026. In early October the State filed a motion to revoke his bond, and a warrant was served on Oct. 8. He has stayed in custody since then.

The Lawrence County Prosecutor’s Office prosecuted the case. Tegarden was represented by attorney David Shircliff.

Case No. 47D02-2512-F2-00141

Tegarden also faces a separate case in Monroe Circuit Court 5, which was filed in October. In that case he is charged with:

  • Possession of Methamphetamine (less than 5 grams) with a prior dealing conviction, a Level 5 felony
  • Possession of a Narcotic Drug (less than 5 grams) with a prior dealing conviction, a Level 5 felony
  • Unlawful Possession of a Syringe, a Level 6 felony
  • Maintaining a Common Nuisance – Controlled Substances, a Level 6 felony
  • Possession of Paraphernalia, a Class C misdemeanor

The charges in the Monroe County case are only accusations. Tegarden is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

Monroe County Case No. 53C05-2610-F5-000972

Share this article
Share

Written by

Read next

Springville Man Completes Problem Solving Court, Felony Drug Convictions Entered as Misdemeanors

Springville Man Completes Problem Solving Court, Felony Drug Convictions Entered as Misdemeanors

BEDFORD – A 28-year-old Springville man was sentenced Monday in three drug cases after he successfully completed Lawrence Superior Court II’s Problem Solving Court program. Ethan Ray New appeared Nov. 2 before Judge Robert R. Cline. New spent nearly two years in the program. Because he finished it, the court entered his two felony drug convictions as Class A misdemeanors. New pleaded guilty in all three cases in January 2025. The court took his pleas under advisement while he went through Prob
By Lawrence County Independent News •

Appeals Court Reinstates Charges Against Lawrence County Man, Jury Trial Set for March 2027

The Indiana Court of Appeals has reversed a Lawrence County judge’s decision to throw out criminal charges against Jeremy A. Small. The court ruled that Small waited too long to object to a trial date that fell outside Indiana’s one-year speedy trial deadline. The three-judge panel handed down its ruling on November 5, 2026. Judge Mathias wrote the decision, and Judges Pyle and Weissmann concurred. The same day, Lawrence Superior Court 2 reinstated all four charges and set a new jury trial for
Appeals Court Reinstates Charges Against Lawrence County Man, Jury Trial Set for March 2027

Springville Man Completes Problem Solving Court, Felony Drug Convictions Entered as Misdemeanors

BEDFORD – A 28-year-old Springville man was sentenced Monday in three drug cases after he successfully completed Lawrence Superior Court II’s Problem Solving Court program. Ethan Ray New appeared Nov. 2 before Judge Robert R. Cline. New spent nearly two years in the program. Because he finished it, the court entered his two felony drug convictions as Class A misdemeanors. New pleaded guilty in all three cases in January 2025. The court took his pleas under advisement while he went through Prob
Springville Man Completes Problem Solving Court, Felony Drug Convictions Entered as Misdemeanors

Mitchell Mother and Son Sentenced to IDOC for Dealing Methamphetamine After Seizure of Over 70 Grams

A joint mother-son narcotics investigation conducted by the Lawrence County Sheriff’s Office has concluded with prison sentences in Lawrence Superior Court 1 for both defendants. Alicia A. Claffey, 49, and her adult son, Cody A. Powell, 21, both of Mitchell, were sentenced to the Indiana Department of Correction (IDOC) after entering negotiated plea agreements with the State of Indiana for dealing methamphetamine. According to the Lawrence County Prosecutor’s Office, the convictions stem from
Mitchell Mother and Son Sentenced to IDOC for Dealing Methamphetamine After Seizure of Over 70 Grams

Police Log 11/17/2026

Bedford Police Department & Lawrence County Sheriff's Department Public Safety Log: November 16 – 17, 2026 All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Incident Highlights * Personal Injury Collisions: * 630 Lincoln Ave (Bedford): Bedford Police and emergency medical responders handled a motor vehicle collision with injuries on Nov. 16 at 3:09 PM. * 12th St (Bedford): BPD, Lawrence County Sheriff's deputies, and EMS responded to an active personal injury
Police Log 11/17/2026

Police Log 11/16/2026

Bedford Police Department & Lawrence County Sheriff's Department Public Safety Log: November 15 – 16, 2026 All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Arrests & Citations * Juvenile (Female, 14), Bedford: Cited/Apprehended by Bedford Police at 1800 block of I St on Nov. 15 at 3:10 PM for Minor Consuming an Alcoholic Beverage. * Juvenile (Male, 17), Bedford: Cited/Apprehended by Bedford Police at 1800 block of I St on Nov. 15 at 3:10 PM for Minor Consuming an
Police Log 11/16/2026

Police Log 11/14/2026

Bedford Police Department & Lawrence County Sheriff's Department Public Safety Log: November 12 – 14, 2026 All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Incident Highlights * Personal Injury Collisions: * Hobson Ford (10050 SR 37, Mitchell): Emergency medical responders and Lawrence County Sheriff's deputies responded to a motor vehicle accident with personal injuries on Nov. 12 at 8:03 AM. * Little Salt Creek Run (Heltonville / Bedford): First responders,
Police Log 11/14/2026